Who???

i think she is real but people think it is fake

http://www.snopes.com/horrors/ghosts/winstead.asp

i dnt no if it is true or nt n i dnt really wanna find out

I KNOW SHE IS REAL BECAUSE I WAS SCARED WHEN I GOT THIS YEARS AGO BUT I SENT IT TO 10 PEEPS BUT I ASKED MY MOM AND SHE SAID ONCE SHE HERD IT ON THE NEWS IT IS REAL BUT IT POPED UP NOW AND MY COMPUTER WONT GO ON E-MAIL SO IM SCREWED AND I HAVE TO GO TO THE BATHROOM!!!!! OHHHH!!=0

http://www.snopes.com/horrors/ghosts/winstead.asp

No this is not true. Go to google and look it up just like it says. There are no available news links, no record of this ever happening.

idk nd i dont wanna find out so i sent it 2 10 ppl. now im afraid 2 shower, go 2 the bathroom nd sleep. =(

i think the story might be true but all of this other nonsince is probably just added on for a good laugh.

Im so scard right now i dont even want to know but i did send it to 10 and more so thatjust in case i didnt count right i still wouldnt die OMG im still scared But i do think that the story is beleavable and true unfortenitley tell me what you think and e-mal me at sarabama96@aol.com

haha you guys dont be so silly ive looked at a hundred of these and never reposted it and im still alive to be typing this right now. so yeah its not true.

Well at least i know im not the only loser looking this upp. i dont really believe this stuff but i dont know i got bored and someone sent me the chain on my cell and yeah ive read several different links. this isnt true. and if you go to the "snopes" link or what the hell ever you'll see that its not true and that thye are using different names. this is fake fake fake and they also have 0 news on this girl :p haha jeeze. that is all

I got scared when i first got this message. Well really i was more curious than scared. I looked this up all over google and there was at least about 6 or more websites saying this is a fake urban legend. Some girls made it up on myspace and there were no police reports on this, And the only ppl that say its true is this werido on youtube. Who made a video that didn't explain crap. Lol even if it is true dont you think u would hear about it now days. And if it is on the news they probally talking about how fake it is. Truely i think its a dumb story that i could have thought up. Well i guess i'll see fer shure when i go to bed today. L8ter

for all of u out there who are scared, y r u? how would "carmen" or "jessica" know if you opened the message. that chain is on myspace, AIM, email, and on cell phones. its been circulating for 2 years! i think the dead girl knows that enough people know she was pushed. i looked on google. its an urban legend. i know u cant tell urself that it isnt true and not be scared if u already are. sleep with a sign on urself saying "i know u were pushed, sorry" if u are really that scared.

this is plain FAKE! whoever is scared.DONT BE cause yeah to me i think this i fake just like all the other fake chain letters:))

you know i dont think this story is true but i got the text this morning and it was a picture of her and the story on the bottom. i read it and i got the chills. i was kinda disturbed by it. when i tried to forward it it wasnt sending and i started to get even more paranoid. when i would try to forward it all my phone kept doing was turning off and on. i even forwarded some of my other messages because i thought it was my phone but it wasnt that. i got scared and woke up my aunt to let her read it. i dont know what that was all about but it really scared the shit out of me!!!!!!!! Leticia Camacho

its a bunch of bullshit!!!! this is like soooooo fake!!!!!!!!!!!who ever said this "now im afraid 2 shower, go 2 the bathroom nd sleep."is a fukin retard................dumbshits!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Look if your scared fine. if your not fine, but i know that a ghost can't kill you! so why be afraid of something that can't kill you?. They make you kill yourself! you touchier yourself till you do it your darn self so she don't get you!so go to sleep and if you wake up and she is there, then tell her your sorry, but your not going to die tonight! Plus you don't even know where she died or anything so how do you know she'll get you?! Ghost stay where they died and haunt the ground they died. NOT THE WHOLE WORLD!!! so there for it's not true!

i heard that she is dead and that she did get killed but not like dat i think its aload ov shit i mean asif ur realli gonna go missin in the middle ov the night hu gonna take ya a robber haha...... i mean it is a belivable story but its just common sence ov course its not true !! :):)

ya'll mothafuckas are a bunch of fucking pussy's..i mean damn do you honestly think a ghost would kill you nnnnaaahhh fuck that..i've read a million of these stupid ass blogs on myspace and i don't repost n/e of that shit why? cause how the fuck is a ghost gonna kill you..and plus you don't even know if that shit was true so chill sit back relax and smoke one to the head if you want to lol fuck this homo shit ima get faded

Well i dont know for sure if it is true but i got a text about hmm probably an hour ago it told me to look up her name on google so i did and i was very disturbed to find out that she was actully posted on the internet! Im not completely freaked out by it but it does scare me a little i showed it to my freinds and they thought it was bull but you never know things turn out to be real i did'nt forward it because i dont know if i should i mean it does sound completely stupid i mean really but at the same time i kinda feel unaware of anything thats gunna happen

Ok seiroucly look you get these chain letters a million times such as if you dont foward this you will die in the next to hours. ok come on do you really think you are going to die? This is no diffrent only for the fact that they say its on google thats only to make you think it is true. I never belive in this stuff and never will I have gotten million of these and look i am still alive. IF you belive in this stuff Im sorry but ur an idiot. If you really think you are going to die have fun.

yall are stupid dont be cryin home to mama scared cuz yu thought yu saw a ghost. THEY ARE REAL people have gotten live videos of that shit but go head dont respond but they will come and get you muthafuckas oh and one more thing my fathers a ghostologist and hes seen them furreal but yeah dont send the chain letters im sure yu wont be killed by a ghosty. GUD NIGHT AND DONT LET THE CARMEN WINSTEAD BITE! HOLLLLLAAAAA

no..they have no proof that this story is real. it was made up by 3 stupid girls on myspace so they could see how many friends they could make. there is also an alternate version using the name jessica smith. exact same story, just different names.nbut no, this story isnt true.

its supost to be an urban myth

Noooo its not because if it was true they would have had been on the news and it would have been in the newspaper..ive got tons of these never send them im still here..they are so stupid..so no its not true!

The story of her is REAL. Keep telling yourself that its not and see what happens. At first shell give you a warning or a sign just like she did me. I was looking up her name after I got the text, and was reading through a few websites that were talking about her. Then... I got to one were it was saying how she is NOT REAL... and how the story is not true at all. After reading more and more about it i start believeing that it is all BS.. as I continued reading.. and believe these lies my nose starts to bleed terrible out of nowhere.. It was a sign..SHE IS REAL. and for all of you that think shes not you better respect her and watch out.

The Carmen Winstead story is a classic Internet "urban legend." The story started on MySpace from three teenage girls trying to see how many friends they could get from it. According to the story, Carmen was accidentally killed when her "friends" pushed her down a sewer. Now she will visit a horrible death upon anybody who doesn't post her story on their MySpace page. Later versions of this story were sent as more conventional e-mail chain letters. There's also a nearly identical version with a victim named Jessica Smith. There is NO news report from any reliable news agency that records any story similar to the Carmen Winstead / Jessica Smith hoaxes. This according to snopes who checks these things with an unblinking eye.

noooooooooo i found out that it's not true because i didn't send it for 3 to 4 days and im still here so don't even bother to believe in it it was made up by some girls who wanted to get some friends on myspace and they ended up scaring people on accident.

lol its so funny how many people actually looked her up on google as if theres whole webpages dedicated to this sillyness there are hundreds of those stupid bulletins everyday no one is going to die from then and if you truely beleive a bulleten could kill you then you are mentally retarded (Y) i didnt look it up cuz i thought i was going to die,i looked it up to see if the story was true,cuz the whole bein pushed down a sewer by her freinds didnt really cut it for me :) & now i kno it isnt true i can just laugh at you people who think it is

its nt true there is no way its true how would they know if you opened the text message or not and there isnt alot of sewers that can just open right up and you fall in it haha this is a made up story!

The carmen winstead story is completely fictional. we looked up many stories about her and they were all false. It is just a "chain message" that was posted on myspace or sent through text message. there is no Factual information found abou her.so inthat case it is totally fiction. just because girls on myspace tried to get friends from it.

first of all if this thing were true how will she kill u from ur toilet reach out and grab ur cock, rip it off and let u bleed to death, and a shower oh no some ugly dead chicks falling out of my shower its the opposite of my fantasy and if theese things really did kill you anyone who sent them to you and you did die could be charged with attempted/or murder god

Wow this story is so messed up! It went from myspace to e-mail and thin to phone. I have figered out that it is impossible for a team of 12 google employes to monitor that many messages in 6 months. So ur telling me that a single girl can do this in ONE night? I don't think so. It is an intersting topic though.

I Never send all them crap things, Because i believe they aren't true, I Just think they are to scare us but then again, If you have it stuck in your head, You might just picture it in your mind? Well that's what i thought anyway, I Haven't sent this one about Carmen Winstead and let's see if i am dead!!!!! If i aint[which i probs wont die] I'll type back tomorrow to see if it's true or not? :S stupid people.

i dunno if it is true but if it is the poor girl. who ever the girls are who pushed her down the sewer are fucked up!!!

That pushed her.....to her I am very sorry. Those girls who pushed her should go to hell. They deserved it not her. (there now if it is or is not true I made everyone happy! :P

all i know is i got the message and freaked out so i sent it cause i dont want to take any chances on it...

im srry about those girls that pushed u carmen i truley am....i hope u have a good time in heaven.....and i hope those dumb girls burn in hell

ok at first i was totally freaked out. i read it on the bus n was so scared that i sent it to like 20 ppl. it says to send to 10. i even convinsed myself that i heard her laughin n the shower. but wen i got home i googled it and it said some girls just made it on myspace. i just wonder if there really is a carmen winstead. i know she wont kill u or hurt u, but i just wanna know if there really was a carmen winstead n girls pushed her down. idk

They hurt her, "About six years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge, the police were called. They went down and brought up 17-year-old Carmen Winstead's body, with her neck broken from hitting the ladder, then the concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them. FACT: About two months later, 16-year-old David Gregory read this post and didn't repost it. When he went to take a shower, he heard laughter, started freaking out, and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but five hours later, his mom woke up in the middle of the night from a loud noise and David was gone. A few hours later, the police found him in the sewer, with a broken neck and the skin on his face peeled off. Even Google her name - you'll find this to be true. If you don't repost this saying "They hurt her," then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep, you'll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill you."

They hurt her a girl was pushe​d down a sewer​ openi​ng by 5 girls​ in her schoo​l,​​​​ tryin​g to embar​rass her in front​ of her schoo​l durin​g a fire drill​.​ ​ ​​ When she didn’​t subme​rge the polic​e were calle​d.​ ​ ​​ They went down and broug​ht up 17 year old Carme​n Winst​ead’s​ body,​​​​ her neck broke​n from hitti​ng the ladde​r,​​​​ and then the side concr​ete at the botto​m.​ ​ ​​ The girls​ told every​one she fell…​ They belie​ved them.​ ​ ​​ FACT:​​​​ 2 month​s ago, 16 year old David​ Grego​ry read this post and didn’​t repos​t this.​ ​ When he went to take a showe​r he heard​ laugh​ter from his showe​r,​​​​ he start​ed freak​ing out and ran to his compu​ter to repos​t this.​ ​ 5 hours​ later​ his mom woke up in the middl​e of the night​ cause​ of a loud noise​.​ ​ David​ was gone.​ ​ That morni​ng a few hours​ later​ the polic​e found​ him in the sewer​,​​​​ his neck broke​n and his face skin peele​d off. Even googl​e her name-​​​​ you’l​l find this to be true If you don’t​ repos​t this sayin​g “They​ Beat Her Up” Then Carme​n will get you, eithe​r from a sewer​,​​​​ the toile​t,​​​​ the showe​r,​​​​ or when you go to sleep​ you’l​l wake up in the sewer​,​​​​ in the dark

NO!!!! myspace legend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I dnt think dat carmen winstead is true....its alll shit lol....well wen I saw it on my brothers phone I was like very scared but then I went 2 google n I searched her nmae but she wasn't true....n I didn't send it 2 people...cuz I knew it was fake...but I thought it was real....so I was thinkin of da both...but I knew it wasn't real but da picture is scary...so I was still kinda scared

ok i hate these kinda things cuz as a single mom who lives in a big ol house all alone wit my kids i am easily scared and i sent it and then apologized to tha ppl i sent it to cuz i know that its annoying ... i agree wit sum other people tho as in a wonder if she really existed sumwhere and it makes me feed even more into it .... its sad and if there is a carmen or jessica then may you rest in peace and may ur murders be sent to hell on judgement day but either way this shyt makes me realize that we live in a sad sick corrupt world and that hurts my heart

I THINK IT IS NOT TRUE I GOOGLED IT ALL IT SAAYS HOW IT WAS MADE UP BY SOME DUMD MYSPACE PPL TO SCARE PPL. AND PLUS IF IT WAS TRUE HOW WELL SHE NOW IF U SENT IT TO SOMEBODY I THINK THE PPL THAT DO THA KIND OF STUDD STUFF IS DUMBER THAN DUMB BECAUSE MY PHONE WOULD NOT LET ME SEND IT AND I WAS SCARED THAT NIGHT BUT I AM STILL HERE so dont beileve this bull shyt as soon as u get it delete it thats wat i do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes. It is true. Once there was a gorl name Carmen Winstead in Indianna. At a fire dril. Five girls pushes her down a sewer to embrass her. I'm guessing these girls hated her a lot. She was missing. No one seen her. The last time they saw her was at the fire drill. People were worried. So they called the police. The police found her in a sewer. She was dead. They asked the girls what happened. They said she fell. The police believed them.

About six years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge, the police were called. They went down and brought up 17-year-old Carmen Winstead's body, with her neck broken from hitting the ladder, then the concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them. FACT: About two months later, 16-year-old David Gregory read this post and didn't repost it. When he went to take a shower, he heard laughter, started freaking out, and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but five hours later, his mom woke up in the middle of the night from a loud noise and David was gone. A few hours later, the police found him in the sewer, with a broken neck and the skin on his face peeled off. Even Google her name - you'll find this to be true. If you don't repost this saying "They hurt her," then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep, you'll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill you. They hurt her

They hurt her About six years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge, the police were called. They went down and brought up 17-year-old Carmen Winstead's body, with her neck broken from hitting the ladder, then the concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them. FACT: About two months later, 16-year-old David Gregory read this post and didn't repost it. When he went to take a shower, he heard laughter, started freaking out, and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but five hours later, his mom woke up in the middle of the night from a loud noise and David was gone. A few hours later, the police found him in the sewer, with a broken neck and the skin on his face peeled off. Even Google her name - you'll find this to be true. If you don't repost this saying "They hurt her," then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep, you'll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill you.

this is so stupid...how would carmen kno if u read the message or not..i got the text message nd i didnt believe it at all cuz i get those all the time....nd even if it was true y would she pick ne random person instead of the ppl who pushed her down ppl need to get lifes....

Hello, i dontt think this is true because, ive been gettingg this email day in and day out, i got it the other day and was terrified to go to sleep, but im still alive and typing this, so it aint true, dont believe such stupid things, yeh i kno it might turn out to be true, but sometimes you just gotta ignore it, i sent it to my little sister who is 10 and she was terrified and sent it to everyone on her hotmail TWICE! someone needs to stop it and i dnt care who it is, i just want it to stop scaring little children and their parents.

sounds like ceek got it of habbo and when i googled it im like good lawd x] so popular - faking bitches if it was true then them girls are satins children nd btw who would fit ina sewer?????? LMAO over think that myspace girls

Bull shit if this is true were are the police reports Your lying if you say it's true Cuz there is no evidece (can't spell worth a shit )

About six years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge, the police were called. They went down and brought up 17-year-old Carmen Winstead's body, with her neck broken from hitting the ladder, then the concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them. FACT: About two months later, 16-year-old David Gregory read this post and didn't repost it. When he went to take a shower, he heard laughter, started freaking out, and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but five hours later, his mom woke up in the middle of the night from a loud noise and David was gone. A few hours later, the police found him in the sewer, with a broken neck and the skin on his face peeled off. Even Google her name - you'll find this to be true. If you don't repost this saying "They hurt her," then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep, you'll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill you. They hurt her

i have researched it and it is sooo not true. Who else here got that email about the murderous clown that would "visit" you at 3:00 am if you didnt forward that message? And who got that message about that guy who didnt forward the email, his cause of death was unknown, and the killer without a face was going to com eof you didnt repost that in 900 seconds? I got both, and i forwarded neither. So i doubt this one is true, either.

nope, its just some freak who wants to scare people. its such a lie. no dead girl would care if u post her story, and she wouldnt kill u anyway. dont freak out!

They hurt her About six years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge, the police were called. They went down and brought up 17-year-old Carmen Winstead's body, with her neck broken from hitting the ladder, then the concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them. FACT: About two months later, 16-year-old David Gregory read this post and didn't repost it. When he went to take a shower, he heard laughter, started freaking out, and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but five hours later, his mom woke up in the middle of the night from a loud noise and David was gone. A few hours later, the police found him in the sewer, with a broken neck and the skin on his face peeled off. Even Google her name - you'll find this to be true. If you don't repost this saying "They hurt her," then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep, you'll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill you. 0 Pts Rate Answer

thay fucked her up

noo dont believe it I get 1000000000's <-- lol of them vereyday and im still living ;]

I think maybe some is true. She DOES NOT haunt people, and she doesn't kill, but she might of gotten pushed down.

I got dis in an email and I sort of freaked...lol. But my mom wouldn't let me repost it cuz of viruses and stuff. So I'm scared to use my own bathroom!!! But people have said that they read it and they're still here so... Carmen if ur real im sorry wat happened 2 u but that isnt a reason to haunt people!!And plz stop! Im scared but i know there is good not just evil and God will help me. Im takin' a bath tonight no showers 4 me!! LoL! I think of it like those emails like you will die if u don't send dis 2 10 people and i never send those so y should i be scared of this one??

I got dis email and I sort of freaked...lol! My mom wouldn't let me repost it cuz of a virus or something. People who r like really scared just email a few friends that got that Carmen or Jessica email and say "if u repost that email could you say something like 'this counts for my friend, _____ too as well as me?'" I did that but im still a bit freaked but I never post the other emails that say "youll die if u don't post" and I'm still here so why am i so freaked about dis email? Just 2B safe, I'm taking a BATH tonight! LOL!

ANY WAY HOW COULD THE EXACT SAME THING HAPPEN 2 2 DIF. GALS. dis is retarted

FALSE

NEXT TIME U GET SUMTIN SCARYISH DELETE IT DONT SEND IT AND NEVER TALK ABOUT OR READ IT AGAIN. wHOS WITH ME?!!!!

hi, i have got a hundrend of these story's and im still alive,i still have eyes,im not in a sewer,and i have a face!this is really fake..... sorry if i ruined this for everyone...later

no it is not

no it is not there is no death record like that ever

no its all just a hoax

Truthfully when I first heard this story I freaked out and I didn't want to take a shower or got to bed or even take a shit.When I went to bed that first night I woke up at 3:00 A.M and didnt go to bed till 5:00A.M I was so scared to go back to bed I turned my light on and kept it on and i have school at 6:00 so I figured im putting an end to this bull shit I started asking my friends if they got the message and they did some belived it some didnt some did.some didnt forward it and they were alive. Then I realized another thing no one could fit in a sewer and theres not enough evidence to make the story true. So dont be scared of this shit its not true its just a bunch of people who want to scare u she wouldnt kill u for no reason if she was real its I figured out that these messages get sent all th time and no ones ever come up dead from not sending so will everyone please please stop getting scared of this if u have to piss piss if u have to shit shit and please take a shower i mean ud throw away ur personal hygiene over text messsage I most certaily wouldnt so dont belive this thatnk u

no it is not people are just trying to scare you and ive read alot of these stupid ass chain letters they are not real it is just a urban legend how does carmen even know that we read it,this stuff is fucked up false

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/carmen-winstead/

I don't buy it. It is not believable.